Saturday, 20 January 2018

FOR ATTN : SHRI RAVI SHANKAR PRASADJI


Aadhar  Fact  :  Privacy  Fiction ?

--------------------------------------




For last two days , Supreme Court is hearing arguments from the petitioners who are opposing Aadhar


For details of arguments advanced by advocate Shyam Divan ( for the petitioners ) and the observations made by the Supreme Court , read :

Aadhar : Supremely Satisfying ?

https://myblogepage.blogspot.in/2018/01/aadhar-supremely-satisfying.html

 


My  Observations  :


For over 60 years, Indians have submitted far more personal data , mostly to dozens of government agencies, to obtain goods or services . All of this was in long paper forms .  No one objected  ! 


Just a few examples are : banking / insurance / gas connection / credit card / income tax / police / driving licence / ration / kerosene / healthcare / school-college admissions / property tax / PF / Passport  etc .


Now the petitioners are objecting to the following information captured by Aadhar form :

     Name  /  Gender   /  Birth date  /   Address  /  Mobile No  /  Email  /  Biometric  /
     Photo

On the other hand, we have been ( voluntarily ) furnishing , a lot of personal information to private parties for decades , even knowing that these parties are either “ selling “ or “ commercially exploiting “ , that information !

Just one example is the following type of personal data which jobseekers make available to Job Portals and URGE them to share it freely with the World ( including blasting of their resumes to unknown employers / recruitment agencies – the governing principle being :  Tell World  About  Me [  TWAM  ]

==================================================

         First Name  /  Middle Name  /  Last  Name  /  Address  /  Current  Location  /
         Photo ( sometimes , optional )  /  Mobile  Number  /  Email  ID  /  Birth Date  /
         Gender  /  Educational  Details ;  Degrees -  Diplomas  -  Colleges  -  Years
        attended  -  Marks  obtained  /  Current  Employer -  Designation  -  Salary  /
        Jobs  held  in past – names of Companies – Periods worked – Salaries drawn –
        Designations held – Reasons for leaving /  Position applying for or interested in
        /  Preferred location  /  Salary expected  /  Current   Industry – Function – Job
       Role  /  Skills acquired  /  Languages spoken – written  /   Area of specialization
       /  Marital  Status  /  Names of  References for checking background / Name of
       Spouse / Number of Children ( with their ages ) etc


====================================================



A few months ago, after Supreme Court held that “ Privacy is a fundamental right “,
Delhi Metropolitan Magistrate ordered a probe against online jobs portal Monster.com for allegedly selling data on website users to a third party.


Before start of the current hearing on 17th , I wish the Supreme Court had read my following email :

A Fool’s Paradise ?  [  29  Aug  2017  ]

https://myblogepage.blogspot.in/2017/08/a-fools-paradise.html

 

=======================================================

  

My  Take  :


Aadhar is Inescapable
 
Modifications / Improvements must continue
 
Privacy  is an Illusion


=======================================================


Why  do I say  that  ?

2024 ! – V 2.0 of Orwellian 1984 ?  [  07  July  2017  ]

Data Protection without Data Privacy ?  [  08  Jan  2018  ]

     https://myblogepage.blogspot.in/2018/01/data-protection-without-data-   privacy.html

 




20  Jan  2018



No comments:

Post a Comment